House Smart Property Group
Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

Mortgages: the right broker

Lending is not one market. The lender that will happily take a self-employed applicant may refuse the flat above a shop. The one that likes the flat may not touch a satisfied default from four years ago. Getting to the right broker matters more than most people realise.

Do you give mortgage advice?

No. House Smart Property Group is not a lender and not a mortgage broker, and we do not give mortgage advice of any kind. We cannot recommend a lender, a product or a rate, and nothing on this page is a recommendation. What we do is understand your circumstances and introduce you to an authorised broker whose experience fits them. All advice comes from that firm, not from us.

First-time buyer mortgage and survey guide

Where things usually get complicated

We are not a broker or a lender
No advice given by us
Matched to a broker who fits your case
Fees disclosed in writing
No obligation

Why it matters

"Computer says no" usually means "this computer says no"

A decline from one lender is not a verdict on you. It is one lender's criteria, applied to one set of facts, on one day. There are dozens of lenders in the UK, many of them intermediary-only — they do not deal with the public at all and you cannot reach them without a broker. Their criteria are frequently where unusual cases get placed.

Criteria

Differ enormously between lenders

One lender wants three years of accounts, another considers one. One ignores a small satisfied default, another declines it. Neither is wrong — they are different businesses with different appetites.

Access

Some lenders you cannot reach yourself

Intermediary-only lenders deal exclusively through brokers. They are often the ones who consider complex income, adverse credit or unusual property.

Specialism

Brokers are not interchangeable

A broker who mostly places straightforward employed applicants may rarely see a contractor buying a timber-framed house. Matching the case to the specialism is usually what decides it.

The awkward questions

Will a lender lend on this?

Below are the situations that most often turn a straightforward application into a difficult one. None of this is advice and none of it is a promise — every lender sets its own criteria and they change constantly. It is here so you know what to raise with a broker at the first conversation rather than discovering it after a valuation.

The property

Spray foam

Insulation in the roof

One of the most common current causes of a decline. Positions vary widely — some lenders refuse outright, some consider it with a satisfactory inspection, some distinguish open-cell from closed-cell. Where it has been removed, evidence of removal and a roof timber inspection are usually wanted.

Construction

Non-standard construction

Concrete prefabs, steel frame, timber frame, single-skin, cob and thatch. Some lenders decline by construction type outright; others consider specific designated types, sometimes with a structural engineer's report.

Cladding

High-rise and external wall systems

Blocks above certain heights may require external wall documentation before a lender will proceed. Requirements have shifted repeatedly, so current lender positions need checking rather than assuming.

Leasehold

Short lease terms

Lenders set minimum unexpired lease terms, commonly requiring a substantial number of years to remain at the end of the mortgage term. A lease shorter than that can stop an application even where everything else is fine.

Commercial

Flats above shops

What is below matters. Many lenders take a different view of a flat above a quiet office than one above a takeaway or a licensed premises, and some decline commercial adjacency altogether.

Ex-local authority

Former council flats and houses

Frequently fine, but some lenders apply restrictions on block height, deck access, or the proportion of privately owned flats in the block.

Japanese knotweed

Invasive plants

Usually a question of proximity and whether there is a treatment plan with an insurance-backed guarantee. Some lenders proceed with one in place; others decline within a set distance regardless.

Annexes

Multiple kitchens or self-contained units

A property with an annexe or a second kitchen can be treated as two dwellings by some lenders, which changes the product entirely — and occasionally the stamp duty position.

Condition

Uninhabitable or unmortgageable

No functioning kitchen or bathroom, serious structural movement or severe damp can make a property unmortgageable on a standard residential product. Bridging and refurbishment finance exist for these cases and are a different market.

Your income

Self-employed

Sole traders and partnerships

Some lenders want three years of accounts, some two, and some will consider one. Where trading has grown, some use the latest year and others average two or three — which can change the borrowing figure substantially.

Company directors

Salary, dividends and retained profit

Some lenders assess salary plus dividends only. Others will use salary plus retained profit in the business, which for a director who leaves money in the company can produce a very different result.

Contractors

Day rate and fixed-term contracts

Some lenders assess contractors on an annualised day rate rather than accounts, which often works in the applicant's favour. Others treat contracting as self-employment and want accounts.

Variable pay

Bonus, commission and overtime

Lenders differ on how much variable income they count — some take 100 per cent of an averaged figure, some 50 per cent, some none. On a commission-heavy income this can be the whole difference.

Zero hours

Irregular and gig work

Not automatically a barrier. Lenders generally look for a track record in the same line of work, and treat length of history very differently from one another.

Benefits

Universal Credit, tax credits and disability benefits

Some lenders count certain benefit income towards affordability and others do not. Which benefits are accepted, and at what proportion, varies considerably.

Later life

Lending into retirement

Maximum age at the end of the term varies widely, and pension income is assessed differently between lenders. Retirement interest-only and later-life products are a separate market.

Foreign nationals

Visas and right to reside

Visa type, time remaining and length of UK residence all affect which lenders will consider an application. Some require indefinite leave to remain; others will lend on certain visa categories.

New to job

Recently started or about to start

Some lenders want three or six months in a role; others will accept a signed contract before the first payslip, particularly where the applicant has stayed in the same profession.

Your credit

Defaults

Registered defaults

Age, value and whether it has been satisfied all matter. Some lenders decline any default within six years; others disregard small satisfied defaults after twelve months.

CCJs

County court judgments

Treated similarly to defaults but generally more seriously. Satisfied CCJs are viewed differently from outstanding ones, and how long ago it was registered is usually the deciding factor.

Missed payments

Arrears on credit or a mortgage

Recent mortgage arrears are viewed more seriously than a missed mobile phone payment. Most lenders look at the last twelve to twenty-four months most closely.

DMP

Debt management plans

Whether the plan is active or settled changes which lenders will consider it. Specialist lenders exist for applicants in an active plan.

Insolvency

Bankruptcy and IVAs

Time since discharge is what matters most. Some lenders require six years from discharge, others three, and a small number less than that.

Thin file

Little or no credit history

Having never borrowed can be as awkward as having borrowed badly, because there is nothing to assess. Being on the electoral roll and holding some form of credit history usually helps.

When the valuation comes in low

A down-valuation is not necessarily the end of the purchase

Survey issues and down-valuations are the biggest single cause of failed sales, at 37.5%. A lender will lend against the lower figure — so either the price moves or the buyer covers the difference. Before assuming the sale is dead, there are usually a few things left to try.

  • Challenge it with evidence. Comparable sales submitted through the broker can and do overturn valuations.

  • Get the defect properly costed. A specialist report often shows a flagged problem to be a fraction of what was assumed — and a real figure is easier to negotiate with than a caveat.

  • Renegotiate on evidence. A costed report gives a defensible basis for a price conversation rather than a guess.

  • Consider a different lender. Lenders instruct different valuers, and different valuers reach different figures on the same property.

  • Ask what the lender actually needs. Sometimes a retention is lifted by evidence of works rather than a price change.

  • Tell your conveyancer early. Your solicitor may need to raise enquiries off the back of it.

A specialist report can help get a flagged defect properly costed, and your conveyancer may need to raise enquiries off the back of a down-valuation — tell them early.

What we actually do

We do the matching. The broker does the advising.

  1. 1

    You tell us the situation

    Property type, how you are paid, anything on your credit file, and where you are up to. No credit check and no application at this stage.

  2. 2

    We work out what it needs

    Whether this is a straightforward high-street case or one that needs a broker who places complex income, adverse credit or unusual property.

  3. 3

    We introduce you

    To an authorised broker whose experience fits. We tell you in writing if we receive a fee. You are under no obligation to use them.

  4. 4

    They take it from there

    All advice, all recommendations and all regulated activity sit with that firm. We stay in the background keeping the rest of your move moving.

Before the first appointment

What a broker will ask you for

Having this together before you start removes one of the most common causes of delay.

  • Photo ID and proof of address. Passport or driving licence, plus a recent utility bill or bank statement.

  • Three months of payslips and bank statements if you are employed.

  • Two to three years of accounts or SA302s with matching tax year overviews if you are self-employed.

  • Evidence of your deposit and where it came from — savings, a gift, or a property sale.

  • Details of existing credit loans, cards, car finance, student loan, and any childcare or maintenance commitments.

  • Anything awkward, said early. A default from 2022 disclosed at the first conversation is a criteria question. Discovered at underwriting, it is a declined application.

Common questions

Mortgages, answered plainly

General information only. None of the answers below is mortgage advice or a recommendation.

No. House Smart Property Group is not a lender and not a mortgage broker, and we do not provide mortgage advice of any kind. We cannot recommend a lender, a product or a rate, and nothing on this page is a recommendation. What we do is understand your circumstances and introduce you to an authorised mortgage broker whose experience fits your situation. All advice comes from that authorised firm.

A mortgage broker assesses your circumstances, compares products from the lenders they have access to, recommends one that suits your situation and handles the application through to offer. A whole-of-market broker can look across most lenders rather than a single lender's own range. Brokers can also access intermediary-only lenders, which do not deal with the public directly and are often the ones that consider unusual income, credit histories or property types.

Because lending is not one market. A broker who mostly places straightforward employed applicants on high-street products may have limited experience of, say, a contractor on a day rate buying a flat above a shop. Brokers develop specialisms — self-employed and complex income, adverse credit, non-standard construction, new build, later life, expat and visa cases, buy to let and portfolio landlords. Matching the case to the right specialist is what usually determines whether it gets an offer.

Self-employment is not a barrier in itself, but lenders treat it very differently from one another. Some require three years of accounts, some two, and some will consider one. Some assess a limited company director on salary plus dividends only, while others will use salary plus retained profit, which can produce a materially different figure. Contractors on a day rate are sometimes assessed on an annualised day rate rather than accounts. Because the variation between lenders is so wide, this is one of the situations where broker experience matters most.

It depends entirely on what the adverse credit is, how much it was for, how long ago it was registered and whether it has been satisfied. Lenders take very different positions: some decline any default in the last six years, some ignore small defaults after twelve months, and specialist lenders exist for applicants with CCJs, defaults, a debt management plan or a discharged bankruptcy or IVA. Rates from specialist lenders are typically higher than mainstream ones. A broker who works with adverse credit will know which lenders' criteria a specific credit history fits.

There is no single list, because every lender sets its own criteria. Property types that commonly cause difficulty include non-standard construction such as concrete prefabs, steel-framed and timber-framed homes, properties with spray foam insulation in the roof, flats above commercial premises, high-rise blocks and buildings with cladding issues, leases with a short unexpired term, ex-local authority flats in blocks above a certain height, single-skin construction, properties with Japanese knotweed, and homes with annexes or multiple kitchens. Some lenders decline these outright while others will consider them, sometimes subject to a specialist report.

Not automatically, but it is one of the most common current causes of a declined application. Lender positions vary considerably: some will not lend at all where spray foam is present in the roof, some will consider it with a satisfactory inspection report, and some distinguish between open-cell and closed-cell foam or between correctly installed and poorly installed systems. Where foam has been removed, lenders generally want documentary evidence of the removal and an inspection of the roof timbers. Lender policy in this area has been changing frequently, so current positions need checking case by case.

A down-valuation means the lender will lend against the lower figure, so either the price is renegotiated or the buyer makes up the difference. Down-valuations and survey findings are the single biggest cause of failed sales, at 37.5 per cent. Options generally include challenging the valuation with comparable sales evidence, obtaining a specialist report so a flagged defect is properly costed rather than assumed, renegotiating the price, or approaching a different lender, since lenders instruct different valuers and can reach different figures.

Your own bank can only offer you its own products and will assess you against its own criteria. If you do not fit them, the answer is no, with no indication of which other lender might have said yes. A whole-of-market broker can compare across lenders and can also access intermediary-only lenders that do not deal with the public at all. Some people do get a good outcome going direct, particularly straightforward cases with an existing lender; the trade-off is that you are seeing one lender's view rather than the market's.

It varies by firm. Some brokers are fee-free and are paid a procuration fee by the lender when a case completes. Others charge a fee to the client, sometimes on application and sometimes on offer, in addition to or instead of the lender's procuration fee. A broker must tell you how they are paid before giving advice, and it will be set out in the documentation they give you at the outset. Ask the question at the first conversation.

Typically photo identification and proof of address, three months of payslips and bank statements if you are employed, or two to three years of accounts or SA302s and corresponding tax year overviews if you are self-employed, evidence of your deposit and where it came from, and details of existing credit commitments. Having these ready before the first appointment removes one of the most common causes of delay in a mortgage application.

An initial conversation and a research-stage credit check are usually a soft search, which is visible to you but not to other lenders and does not affect your score. A full mortgage application involves a hard search, which is recorded on your file and visible to other lenders. Some agreements in principle use a soft search and some use a hard one, so it is worth asking which before proceeding. Multiple hard searches in a short period can affect how lenders view an application.

An agreement in principle, sometimes called a decision in principle or mortgage in principle, is an indication from a lender of how much it might be willing to lend based on the information provided so far. It is not a mortgage offer and is not binding. Estate agents commonly ask to see one before accepting an offer on a property, as evidence that a buyer is in a position to proceed. A full application, valuation and underwriting still follow.

From full application to formal mortgage offer is commonly two to six weeks, though it varies considerably by lender, by how straightforward the case is, and by how quickly documents and the valuation are returned. Cases involving self-employed income, adverse credit or an unusual property type generally take longer because they are more likely to be reviewed by an underwriter rather than assessed automatically.

Mortgage offers have an expiry date, commonly three to six months from issue. If a transaction runs past it, an extension can often be requested from the lender, though this is not guaranteed and the lender may reassess affordability or require updated documents. Where an extension is refused, a new application may be needed. If your chain is running long, tell your broker early rather than close to the expiry date.

Where an introduction leads to a completed case, we may receive a fee from the broker firm. We will tell you in writing before you proceed. You are under no obligation to use any firm we introduce you to, and you are free to approach any broker or lender directly.

Important information

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage.

House Smart Property Group is not a lender and is not a mortgage broker. We do not provide mortgage advice, we do not arrange mortgage contracts, and we do not recommend lenders, products or rates. Everything on this page is general information about how mortgage lending criteria differ between lenders. It is not advice, it is not a recommendation, and it should not be relied on as either.

All mortgage advice is provided by the authorised firm we introduce you to. That firm is responsible for the advice it gives and for the regulated activity it carries out. You are under no obligation to use any firm we introduce you to, and you are free to approach any broker or lender directly.

Lending criteria are set by individual lenders, vary considerably between them and change frequently. Nothing here should be taken as an indication that any lender will or will not lend in any particular set of circumstances.

Where an introduction results in a completed case, we may receive a fee from the broker firm. We will tell you the position in writing before you proceed.

Tell us your situation

Property type, how you are paid, anything on your credit file. No credit check, no application, no advice from us — just a conversation, and then an introduction to a broker who works with cases like yours.

Your home may be repossessed if you do not keep up repayments on your mortgage. House Smart Property Group is not a lender or a mortgage broker and does not give mortgage advice.